Legal Tech Liquidation Lessons
The liquidation of the Taranaki-based law tech startup Firmsy is a salutary tale for startups but also demonstrates the pressures of succeeding in the competitive legal tech space. The firm was placed in voluntary liquidation by founder Claudia King.
In the ever-evolving world of legal technology Firmsy (formerly Automio) serves as both an inspiration and a cautionary tale for entrepreneurs. The business entered voluntary liquidation with debts of $1.5 million.
Claudia King embarked on a mission to revolutionize the legal industry and in 2018 made a Forbes List of 60 leading women-led startups.
According to a Stuff report a first liquidator’s report showed the company owed $225,095 to secured creditors, $92,734 to preferential creditors and $1,245,779 to unsecured creditors.
Liquidator John Scutter said, “Over the last year with the fast changing pace of technology, further investment on the platform has been required.”
“Further investment in the platform was to be financed through further capital issues and equity investment. The issue offers did not generate the level of investment required of further development of the platform.
“Due to limited cashflow from trading and the obligations of the company, a sober assessment of the solvency position of the company was taken by the director.”
Unfortunate End For LawTech Innovation
While Firmsy’s journey has come to an unfortunate end, its impact on the New Zealand legaltech scene is undeniable. The company’s innovative approach and King’s vision and energy have undoubtedly inspired others in the field.
Her journey began at her late father’s law firm, Dennis King Law, where she recognized the need for more efficient document management and greater accessibility to legal services.
King’s vision was clear: create a platform that would streamline legal processes, making them more efficient for lawyers and more accessible for clients who might be hesitant to engage traditional legal services.
This led to the birth of Automio in 2017, later rebranded as Firmsy.
Innovation and Recognition
Firmsy’s innovative approach to legal document automation quickly gained traction. The platform allowed lawyers to create automated legal documents, promising to save time and reduce costs.
The company’s success seemed to validate King’s belief that the traditional billable hour model “sucked” and that there was a better way to build a million-dollar law firm without sacrificing work-life balance.
Her mission resonated with many in the legal community, particularly those seeking to modernize their practices.
The Challenges: Technological Pace and Investment Needs
Despite its promising start, Firmsy faced significant challenges as the legaltech landscape rapidly evolved. The company found itself in need of substantial investment to keep pace with technological advancements and maintain its competitive edge.
King sought additional capital through equity investments, but the response fell short of expectations.
The funding shortfall, combined with limited cashflow from trading, ultimately led to a critical assessment of the company’s solvency.
The Broader Legaltech Landscape
Firmsy’s story unfolds against the backdrop of a growing legaltech sector in New Zealand and globally.
Legaltech startups have surged in recent years, with companies like New Zealand-based inhouse legal platform LawVu, a legal operations platform, and an AI-powered contract review tool, making significant strides.
Internationally, the legaltech market continues to expand, with global investment in legal technology reaching $1.9 billion in 2023, according to Crunchbase data.
This growth reflects the increasing demand for innovative solutions in the legal sector, driven by the need for efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and improved access to justice.
The Firmsy case offers valuable lessons for legaltech entrepreneurs and investors:
- Sustainable growth is crucial as rapid expansion without a solid financial foundation can lead to major issues for the company.
- And the need for continuous innovation within a rapidly expanding area dominated by the development or AI apps places added pressure on innovators.
- The challenge lies in balancing technological advancement with sustainable business practices to create lasting change in the way legal services are delivered and accessed.
Latest Law Jobs
Where some legaltech has tried and failed, others have certainly prospered. There are plenty of excellent legal tech solutions out there which assist legal professionals. Innovative solutions which are changing the legal landscape for the better.
Claudia inspired me to investigate and utilise legal automation.
Automio was (and is) a life-changing platform for me – because of suddenly changing personal circumstances, I could not have continued in legal practice during the crisis periods without that tool which enables me to produce sound legal documentation with minimal human editing.
Claudia and I had some differences of opinion along the way (and I still think she should have persisted with developing Automio in its own right). However, her vision, enthusiasm, and encouragement turned the seemingly impossible into possible.