The Chief Justice’s Annual Report for 2023 provides a comprehensive overview of the New Zealand court system’s performance and challenges.
The report identifies key challenges such as addressing case backlogs, maintaining public confidence, and the need for continued investment in court infrastructure and technology.
>> Here’s Your New Law Job – Inhouse . . Litigation . . Disputes . . Everything
Here’s an analysis of the key points:
Workload and Case Management
The report highlights significant workload pressures across all courts in New Zealand
The Supreme Court experienced a 13% increase in leave applications compared to the previous year, while the Court of Appeal saw a 7% rise in criminal appeals
The High Court faced challenges with an increasing number of complex cases, particularly in the criminal jurisdiction
Timeliness and Efficiency
Despite the increased workload, the courts made efforts to improve timeliness:
- The Supreme Court maintained its target of delivering 90% of judgments within six months of the hearing.
- The Court of Appeal reduced the time taken to deliver judgments in criminal appeals.
- The High Court improved its case disposal rate, particularly in civil matters.
However, the report notes that delays remain a concern, especially in the District Court, where criminal cases are taking longer to resolve
Judicial Resources
The Chief Justice emphasizes the need for additional judicial resources to address the growing workload
The report calls for an increase in the number of judges, particularly in the District Court and High Court, to manage the rising complexity and volume of case
Access to Justice
Improving access to justice remains a key focus:
- The report highlights initiatives to enhance public understanding of court processes1.
- Efforts to improve the experience of litigants in person are mentioned.
- The importance of maintaining open justice while balancing privacy concerns is discussed.
Technology and Modernization
The courts are investing in technology to improve efficiency, including expanding electronic filing systems and enhancing remote hearing capabilities, including –
- Electronic filing systems are being expanded across various courts.
- Remote hearing capabilities have been enhanced, building on lessons learned during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Diversity and Inclusion
The report highlights ongoing efforts to increase diversity within the judiciary, noting progress in appointing more women and individuals from diverse ethnic backgrounds.
- There has been progress in appointing more women and individuals from diverse ethnic backgrounds to judicial roles is noted.
- The importance of a judiciary that reflects the community it serves is stressed.
Challenges and Future Outlook
The Chief Justice identifies several challenges facing the court system:
- The need to address the backlog of cases, particularly in the criminal jurisdiction.
- The importance of maintaining public confidence in the justice system.
- The ongoing requirement for investment in court infrastructure and technology.
The report paints a picture of a court system under pressure but making strides in efficiency, accessibility, and modernization. The Chief Justice’s call for additional resources and continued focus on improving access to justice underscores the ongoing challenges faced by New Zealand’s courts.
